Published 11-20-05
Table hopping – Historic neighborhood restaurants
By Peter DeMarco
Thanksgiving brings to mind turkey dinners, football and, of course, local history. So with the holiday approaching, we turn our attention to Boston’s oldest restaurants. The Union Oyster House and Durgin-Park (both founded in 1826) are the obvious choices, but what about historic neighborhood restaurants? In Southie it’s Amrheins, est. 1890. Cantina Italiana on Hanover Street claims to be the North End’s senior ristorante. And in Chinatown, China Pearl has been serving dim sum on and off for decades. If only the Pilgrims had such choices.
1. S&S Restaurant
(Est. 1919)
1334 Cambridge St.
Inman Square, Cambridge
617-354-0777
The photographs on S&S’s walls retell Inman Square’s history, from the days of horse drawn carriages to the tumultuous 1970s, when the restaurant’s windows were paneled over out of fears of vandalism. But no photo is more striking than Rebecca “Ma” Edelstein’s (cq) large portrait behind the register. “There she is, keeping an eye on the cash receipts for us,” jokes co-owner Gary Mitchell (cq). Mitchell’s great-grandmother founded her Jewish deli on the simple principle of getting good value for your money. Its success has been dizzying: since opening in 1919, S&S has served more than 64 million cups of coffee, 15 million omelets and 2 million slices of apple pie, Mitchell estimates. There’s a crowd be it breakfast, lunch or dinner, and with more than 200 items on the menu - where else in Boston can one order a bagel and lox, Asian chicken salad or a filet mignon? – S&S has a dish for literally every appetite.
2. Santarpio's Pizza
(Est. 1903)
111 Chelsea St.
East Boston
617-567-9871
Cantina Italiana on Hanover Street, founded in 1931, is the North End’s most senior restaurant. But the oldest Italian restaurant in all of Boston stands in Eastie, where Santarpio’s started out in 1903 as a humble bread bakery. “There was only one meal prepared a day, whether it was beef stew, macaroni or tripe on Saturdays. Whatever my great-grandfather felt like making,” says Carla Santarpio, (cq) who runs the restaurant with her brother Frank (cq) and sister Joia. (cq) Their famous thin crust, thick-cheese pizza came along in 1933, according to the family’s 96-year-old matriarch, Anna Timpone (cq). Other than barbequed lamb and sausage plates, it remains the only item on the menu. With lines out the door most nights, no need to ask why.

Frank Santarpio and two freshly made pies. The one on the right is mine. Mushroom!
3. Marliave Restaurant
(Est. 1868)
10 Bosworth St.
Downtown Crossing
617-423-6340
Then again, Frank Iacoviello (cq) thinks his (italics) restaurant is the oldest Italian eatery in Boston. “When they had cows up on the Common, we were here,” he says. The Marliave, established in 1868, predates almost every other local restaurant. But it was a predominantly French restaurant – the first in the city to offer haute cuisine, Iacoviello says – before transitioning to Italian fare in 1935. (As for the cows, they were banned from the Common in 1830.) Regardless, in its day, Café Marliave was as famous as any North End ristorante. Generations of Downtown Crossing shoppers still attest that a trip to Boston wasn’t complete without a bowl of the Marliave’s minestrone soup or a plate of its veal parmigiana, both of which are still on the menu.

The sign is so old, the date has worn off.
4. Doyle’s
(Est. 1882)
3484 Washington St.
Jamaica Plain
617-524-2345
A saloon. A general store. A betting parlor. A speak-easy. Doyle’s has been them all. JP’s eldest restaurant embodies Boston history, from the wooden booths where generations of city politicians talked shop to the photos of Ted Williams on the walls to the 1907 phone booth once used by bookmakers. “Everything you see here is the real McCoy,” boasts mainstay Gerry Burke, (cq) standing near a 1946 menu board featuring a broiled scotch ham dinner for 30 cents. Burke recently passed the business along to his son Gerry Jr. (cq) and partner Chris Spellman, (cq) but nothing’s changed. Crowds still pour in for Doyle’s 32 tap beers – the restaurant was the first ever to serve Sam Adams – tons of dinner specials and hearty weekend brunches. You might even catch Mayor Thomas M. Menino (cq) dining in the room named in his honor.
5. Amrheins
(Est. 1890)
80 West Broadway
South Boston
617-268-6189
Downtown businessman Rick Putprush,(cq) beer in hand, surveyed Amrhein’s spacious new bar room early Wednesday night and gave his review. “Welcome to the 21st century,” he said. South Boston’s oldest restaurant re-opened this week a year after closing for a massive renovation, and while the dark wooden façade on West Broadway remains untouched, returning customers are bound to be surprised when they step inside. Owner Stephen Mulrey (cq) has gone from three rooms to two while replacing every seat, table, booth and lighting fixture in the 115-year-old establishment. Even the bar’s old tin ceiling has given way to a richly lighted vaulted one. Still, efforts have been made to retain much of the restaurant’s old-time character. Photos of legendary mayor James Michael Curley, the restaurant’s adopted patron (he never really dined there, Mulrey said) are omnipresent; the new furniture is rich and dark like before; the carved wooden bar back, dating to 1890, still rests behind the beer taps. New executive chef Janice Silva, (cq) formerly of Le Meridien, says more upscale dishes will dominate the menu. (First-night customers raved about the pork chops and pan-fried chicken parmigiana.) Still, a smattering of old favorites, such as the grilled marinated sirloin tips, are sticking around. “The building was showing its age,” says Pamela Coe, (cq) Amrhein’s president, about the 8-month renovation. ‘‘We tried to mix the old and the new.’’ Will some regulars miss the outdated but familiar version of Amrhein’s? Probably. But far more, customers said, will be glad it’s back. “It was tough when it closed down. My whole family used to come here for dinners and brunch,” said Tim Berardinelli, (cq) 24, of Dorchester, dining with friends. “The food’s better now. And we like the new flatscreens.”
6. China Pearl Restaurant
(Est. 1960)
9 Tyler St.
Chinatown
617-426-4338
Chinatown’s first restaurant, Hong Far Low, (cq) opened in 1879 and thrived for about 75 years, locals say. But try finding a present-day eatery with such longevity, and you’ll be out of luck. China Pearl on Tyler Street, which opened in 1960, comes closest to patriarchal status. For years its grand dining room drew customers from across the city in search of late night food, and its dim sum was not to be reckoned with. China Pearl’s current owners close up at 10:30 p.m. and have changed the restaurant’s Chinese name to Lung Fung, which means “the dragon and the phoenix,” traditional symbols of China’s emperor and empress. But the restaurant façade still reads China Pearl, the place still serves a great dim sum, and its large, albeit dated, dining room is still one of the top places in Chinatown for parties and celebrations.
Inside Scoop: I bit off more than I could chew with this topic. The printed version got significantly trimmed for space, but I credit David Abel with maintaining the integrity of the piece. It's really my fault: I turned in 1,000 words for a 700-word space. But the topic was so rich and interesting and
hadn't been written about. I've got to learn to save such good ideas from table hop and pitch them for bigger spaces, or even the Food section. Mark my words: my next table hop will be under 800 words.
Since Tom Sheehan has bagged me on a few mistakes recently I took extra pains to report the hell out of this story. It took me a week, and I made just $325 on it, including photos, which sucks. But it's a good piece of journalism. My source list, ala Columbia days:
The Boston Business Heritage Project report, 1997, city office of business and development
Pam Dunaroma, editor, The Post Gazette, North End’s newspaper
Chinese Historical Society of Boston
Wing-Kai To, Bridgewater State College professor
Charlie Rosenberg, Jamaica Plain Historical Society
Frank and Kay Chan, former owners of China Pearl
Interviews with about a dozen restaurant owners not mentioned in the story
Somerville Historic Commission
Somerville Museum
Cambridge Historical Society
Cambridge Chamber of Commerce
Ernie Torgerson, director east boston main streets
Central Square Business Association
Charles Sullivan, City of Cambridge planning department
Extensive Internet research
Zagat Survey 2005/6
One other thing that didn't make it in the story, though I wish the hell it did: Santarpio's really is a dive, and it's so cramped that people picking up take out walk into the kitchen and pay for it there. On weekend nights like a dozen people can be crammed in there as if they were family. It's insane, but it works, and you know, it's kind of nice. Almost forgot -
Amrheins is in blue because it appeared as a seperate story in the paper, though it was orginally part of the table hop.